Skip to content
PolarStock

Addressing the Continent's National Populists: Shielding the Less Well-Off from the Winds of Transformation

More than a year after the vote that handed Donald Trump a clear-cut return victory, the Democratic party has yet to released its election autopsy. But, last week, an prominent liberal advocacy organization published its own. The Harris campaign, its writers argued, failed to connect with core constituencies because it failed to concentrate enough on tackling basic economic anxieties. By prioritising the menace to democracy that Trumpist populism represented, liberals overlooked the bread-and-butter issues that were uppermost in many people’s minds.

A Warning for European Capitals

While Europe prepares for a turbulent era of politics from now until the end of the decade, that is a lesson that needs to be fully absorbed in European capitals. The White House, as its newly released national security strategy makes clear, is optimistic that “nationalist movements in Europe will soon mirror Mr Trump’s success. Within Europe's core nations, Marine Le Pen’s National Rally (RN) and Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) lead the polls, backed by significant segments of blue-collar voters. But among mainstream leaders and parties, it is difficult to see a strategy that is adequate to troubling times.

Era-Defining Challenges and Expensive Solutions

The issues Europe faces are costly and historic. They include the war in Ukraine, sustaining the momentum of the green transition, addressing demographic change and building economies that are more resilient to pressure by Mr Trump and China. According to a Brussels-based research institute, the new age of global instability could necessitate an additional €250bn in annual EU defence spending. A major study last year on European economic competitiveness demanded substantial investment in shared infrastructure, to be financed in part by jointly held EU debt.

Such a economic transformation would stimulate growth figures that have stagnated for years.

But, at both the EU-wide and national levels, there continues to be a lack of boldness when it comes to generating funds. The EU’s so-called “budget hawks resist the idea of collective borrowing, and EU spending plans for the next seven years are deeply timid. In France, the idea of a wealth tax is widely supported with voters. Yet the beleaguered centrist government – though desperate to cut its budget deficit – will not consider such a move.

The Cost of Inaction

The reality is that without such measures, the less affluent will bear the brunt of financial adjustment through austerity budgets and increased inequality. Acrimonious recent disputes over retirement reforms in both France and Germany testify to a developing struggle over the future of the European social model – a phenomenon that the RN and the AfD have eagerly leveraged to promote a politics of welfare chauvinism. Ms Le Pen’s party, for example, has opposed moves to raise the retirement age and has said that it would focus any benefit cuts at non-French nationals.

Avoiding a Strategic Advantage for Nationalists

In the US, Mr Trump’s promises to protect blue‑collar interests were deeply disingenuous, as subsequent Medicaid cuts and tax breaks for the wealthy demonstrated. Yet without a convincing progressive alternative from the Harris campaign, they proved effective on the campaign trail. Without a fundamental change in fiscal policy, societal agreements across the continent risk being ripped up. Governments must steer clear of giving this political gift to the Trumpian forces already on the march in Europe.

The writer

John Waller

A passionate urbanist and writer, Elara shares her experiences and research on city dynamics and personal development.

PolarStock

Type to search articles.